Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


WTC cleanup triggers safety, cost allegations
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

USA: October 10, 2001


NEW YORK - While much of New York may be uniting in the wake of the Sept. 11 air attacks, catastrophe specialists and janitors are engaged in a fierce battle for contracts to clean offices and apartments covered in dust and debris.


The cleaning contracts are eventually likely to be worth millions of dollars and provide jobs for thousands of workers - some of them displaced by the attacks, which destroyed the twin towers and several other buildings at downtown New York's World Trade Center.

But the effort is being hampered by differing views on how hazardous the debris materials are and whether specialist firms must be contracted.

At the heart of the debate is asbestos - a fiber used as a fire retardant in parts of the World Trade Center - which can cause lung scarring (asbestosis) and cancer if inhaled over a sustained period.

While the authorities say the levels of asbestos in the air around the World Trade Center site is not dangerous, companies which handle hazardous materials say the dust that has settled in and on surrounding buildings still needs to be handled with great care.

They allege that workers who until a few weeks ago were janitors are unqualified, unprotected, and uninsured to handle this kind of cleanup.

"What looks clean is not clean. What remains are the small pieces that are the real risk," said Michael O'Reilly, chief executive of Trade-Winds Environmental Restoration, Inc., the division of Windswept Environmental Systems Inc. that has sent over 400 trained and certified hazardous material specialists to work for "Fortune 100 firms" at more than a dozen sites. Trade-Winds workers say they have seen janitors handling potentially toxic dust, O'Reilly said.

"We'll be cleaning up after them for maybe six months," O'Reilly said.

JANITORS, UNIONS

The criticism represents a dilemma for ABM Industries Inc., the nation's No. 1 public building maintenance firm. ABM saw nearly 1,200 workers, most of them janitors, displaced when the company's $65 million World Trade Center contract - which was its largest - disappeared when the attacks destroyed the complex and claimed nearly 5,600 lives.

ABM President Henrik Slipsager said the company worked out a deal with the Service Employees International Union to offer the displaced workers temporary jobs until new permanent positions can be found.

One Source, the No. 2 public janitorial services company and a unit of the Carlisle Group Plc., has had 400 janitors out of work at eight buildings in lower Manhattan since the attacks.

Allen Marquesano, the company's New England Regional Manager, says One Source has been sending some of its displaced janitors into New York's financial district - previously home to up to 30,000 people and thousands of businesses.

One Source janitors are equipped with Occupational Safety and Health Administration-approved respirators and 30 brand new $500 high-efficiency particle vacuum cleaners.

"We don't need the money - we (provide for) our clients the service where and when it's safe," Marquesano said, adding that One Source workers have seen companies that jumped the gun to get work doing decontamination for which they had questionable training.

"I've seen guys who are normally doing computer dusting trying to do decontamination," Marquesano said. "Their guys are even less qualified than ours."

BUILDING OWNERS

Caught in the middle of the finger pointing between hazardous materials workers and janitors are the building owners who are trying to get their buildings cleaned up enough to reopen.

Brookfield Properties hired, among others, Hillman Environmental, to handle the "heavy dirt" that spilled through the 600 broken windows at its One Liberty Plaza building, just across the street from the World Trade Center, said the company's president Rick Clark. It then sent his company's regular janitorial services company, Triangle, in to do the "fine stuff," he said.

"They'll have to do that several times over," said Clark referring to Triangle's detail work.

The dispute has also led to threats of legal action by labor unions against some of the building owners and the New York City government. They claim the real estate compa


Story by Jonathan Landreth


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

CANADA:
Canada Opposition Liberals Adjust Carbon Tax Plan

HAITI:
Cat 4 Hurricane Ike Fiercer, Hanna Strengthens

INDIA:
Small Quake Hits Near India-China Border - USGS

INDIA:
India Appeals for Families to Evacuate From Floods

NETHERLANDS:
Dutch Venue Makes Clubbing Environmentally Friendly

NORWAY:
Gull Sets Arctic Pollution Record for Birds

UK:
UK Approves Building of Major Offshore Wind Farm

US:
California "Water Bank" in Works Amid Drought

US:
Demand Seen Thin in First US Greenhouse Auction



previous day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant