Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


FEATURE - Japan clings to whaling past, hopes to lift ban
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

JAPAN: April 24, 2002


WADA - Yoshinori Shoji is a whaler, as his father and grandfather were before him, but his boat is now one of just a handful still working in Japan.


It is his dream that the family tradition will carry on - a dream impossible, he says, without the resumption of commercial whaling and permission to hunt minke whales.

"We are managing to stay in business now, barely," he lamented in Wada, a town some 60 km (38 miles) southeast of Tokyo. "But unless we are allowed to take minkes, I don't know how long we can go on."

Japan, along with fellow whaler Norway, will press for the resumption of commercial whaling at the annual meeting of the International Whaling Commission (IWC) that starts on Thursday in the southwestern city of Shimonoseki.

This effort is likely to fail, as it has before, with divisions between the pro-whaling camp and those who oppose it increasingly deep and the issue emotionally fraught.

Yet even though it faces fierce opposition from around the globe, Japan - usually the most sensitive of nations to foreign opinion - remains determined to keep on whaling.

MYSTICAL ATTACHMENT

Some Japanese are pro-whalers for the most practical of reasons, blaming whales for falling fish catches, for example. Others - especially older people, among them policy makers - have an almost mystical attachment to the mammal.

In old whaling areas, like those around Shimonoseki, whale was believed to bring prosperity and was ritually eaten on certain days for good luck.

Hiroshi Goto, a university student, said the Japanese had always respected whales as crafty and intelligent opponents.

"Westerners look down on what they eat, like pigs and cows," he said. "We respect whales, even as we eat them."

In more recent memory, whale meat helped Japn through the difficult years after World War Two, providing an important source of protein for the impoverished nation.

"There are times in the past when whale saved Japan," said Tetsuji Fukuyoshi, owner of a Shimonoseki firm selling seaweed.

Japan's current stance may even stem from a primal fear that giving in on whaling could leave it vulnerable to demands that it stop taking other kinds of fish.

Two years ago, for example, Japan was at odds with Australia and New Zealand over its research fishing of tuna, without which no sushi dinner is complete.

These days, whale meat has now become a scarce, luxury food item that is rarely eaten, a situation some find puzzling.

"For us, whales are the same as fish," said Yuichiro Harada, an official with the Federation of Japan Tuna Fisheries. "Protecting only whales seems contradictory."

HUNGRY WHALES

Japan agrees with protecting endangered whale species, but argues that others, such as the minkes, are in no danger of dying out and that hunting within limits should be allowed.

Moreover, it says the whales consume such vast amounts of fish that they have contributed to a drop in Japanese fish landings by half, to six million tonnes, over the last 20 years.

This has sparked stark portrayals by pro-whaling groups of whales pitted against humans for cherished, and dwindling, fish in one of the world's largest fish-eating nations.

At a recent festival in Shimonoseki, people hawked t-shirts showing bloated, burping whales and the slogan: "Whales are increasing, fish are decreasing. People are in trouble."

"Since commercial whaling ended in 1986, the number of whales has risen, and they eat a lot of fish, often the same kinds we have on our dinner tables," said Noriyoshi Hattori at the Japan Whaling Association.

"Unless we do a certain amount of thinning of the whales, we risk unbalancing the ecology of the seas."

Anti-whalers and others outside Japan suggest that factors such as overfishing and pollution have taken a larger toll.

"Whales do eat a lot of fish," said Dr. Ray Gambell, a British whale biologist and longtime IWC secretary until he retired two years ago. "But I personally am not totally sympathetic to what they are saying.

"I certainly would be very hesitant to say we must catch the whales to reduce the number of fish they eat."


Story by Elaine Lies


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
24 APR 2002
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Australia govt berates Rio unit over uranium leak

BELGIUM:
UPDATE - EU moots Europe-wide nuclear safety standard

CANADA:
Jack Wells owns an electronics store in a small coastal Canadian town

CANADA:
Canada creates new drought-tolerant canola species

CHINA:
China to clean up southern waters affecting HK

DENMARK:
Alcoa in talks on Iceland aluminium smelter

INDIA:
INTERVIEW - Small islands could drown, warns climate body chief

INDIA:
Climate body chief sees declining use of oil, coal

INDONESIA:
Indonesia says China ponders investment in mining

JAPAN:
FEATURE - Japan clings to whaling past, hopes to lift ban

JAPAN:
No comment on Japan nuclear fuel return date - BNFL

NETHERLANDS:
Greenpeace plans protests against ExxonMobil

NEW ZEALAND:
Whaling, trade talks to dominate Koizumi's NZ visit

REPUBLIC OF IRELAND:
Irish Sellafield protesters in postal blitz on UK

SINGAPORE:
INTERVIEW - Thailand to swap farm surplus for clean air

SOUTH AFRICA:
South Africa says Earth Summit 2 preparations on track

UK:
Ethics can be profitable, says UK's Co-Op Bank

UK:
Britain must invest in nuclear power - govt adviser

UK:
Shipping CO2 could help Norway hit Kyoto targets

USA:
Whooping cranes return on their own to Wisconsin

USA:
US, EU at odds on global warming despite meeting

USA:
Senate's Reid backs compromise on greenhouse gases

USA:
US farmland, forests can absorb greenhouse gases

USA:
Business groups lobby to save SUVs in California

USA:
US Senate to consider $14 bln in energy tax breaks

USA:
CORRECTED - WRAPUP - Gore blasts Bush environment record on Earth Day



previous day
today's news
next day