UN wants to end confusion about Chernobyl
Date: 27-Apr-04
Country: AUSTRALIA
Author: Louis Charbonneau
The disaster occurred 18 years ago, at 1:24 a.m. on April 26, 1986, when an explosion at Reactor 4 of the Ukrainian power plant spewed a cloud of radioactivity across Europe and the Soviet Union.
Around 30 people died from radiation exposure after the accident, nearly 2,000 children later developed thyroid cancer and thousands of other fatal illnesses have been blamed on it. More than 100,000 people were resettled, causing physical, economic and psychological hardship.
Among the millions of people whose lives were affected by the disaster, thousands may have developed cancer and died as a result. But poor records and corruption have prevented the accurate registration of the workers who helped put out the fire and entomb the smouldering nuclear plant in 1986.
"We have an epistemological problem," said Abel Gonzalez, head of radiation and waste safety at the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
"In Chernobyl, you can say that the only concrete sick persons that you can (identify) are the (1,800) children who got thyroid cancer and the workers who were over-exposed. All the rest, we don't know."
Not only is there a limit to the ability of the nuclear experts to understand the full impact of Chernobyl, but contradictory studies and statements about the disaster have confused the millions of people whose lives were affected by it.
"People living in the affected villages are very distressed because the information they receive - from one expert after another turning up there - is inconsistent. People living there are afraid for their children," Gonzalez explained.
Over the years, wildly varying reports have put the Chernobyl death toll as high as 15,000.
For this reason, the IAEA has established the Chernobyl forum, whose task will be to give "authoritative, transparent statements that show the factual situation in the aftermath of Chernobyl," said Gonzalez, who represents the IAEA on the forum.
The forum will bring together Ukraine, Russia and Belarus, the IAEA and all other U.N. organisations involved in Chernobyl. It will review all the studies and statements on Chernobyl, filter out the good, throw out the bad and present a clear summary to next year's U.N. General Assembly.
REGISTRATION WAS DISASTROUS
A native of Argentina, Gonzalez is no stranger to the Chernobyl story. From 1989 to 1991, he headed a huge IAEA study of the health, environmental and radiological impact of the disaster on villages and towns in Russia, Belarus and Ukraine that suffered the worst contamination.
He was always convinced that many cases of leukaemia would appear among the 600,000 so-called "liquidators" who worked frantically in the spring of 1986 to put out the fire in the molten reactor and entomb the plant in a concrete sarcophagus.
"I was personally convinced that leukaemia in the workers - the liquidators - would be detected. But until now it has not appeared," he said.
Gonzalez said that this may be because some of the people who were granted the status of "liquidator", which gave them free public transport and other perks, never actually worked at Chernobyl but got liquidator cards through contacts.
"I saw this with my own eyes," he said. "Someone with the liquidator card who never worked there."
As a result the liquidator register is almost useless.
"If proper registration had been done, probably you would have seen some leukaemia in workers. But the registration is such a disaster that it will be very, very difficult," he said.
Because of this, the question of how many people have died as a result of the accident may never be properly answered.
"It is an issue that is impossible to settle because there are two different types of deaths - the deaths that you can check that they happened and the ones you can only imagine."
BLAMING CHERNOBYL
The Soviet Union's misinformation and overall mismanagement of the disaster resulted in a tendency of victims to attribute all kinds o