Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


EU experts fail to agree on GMO maize imports
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

BELGIUM: September 22, 2004


BRUSSELS - The European Union laid open its deep divisions over the safety of biotech foods this week, postponing a vote on whether to allow imports of a gene-modified (GMO) maize made by U.S. firm Monsanto (MON.N: Quote, Profile, Research) , officials said.


EU environment experts representing the bloc's 25 member states failed to muster enough votes under the bloc's complex decision-making process either to approve or reject Monsanto's application. The date of their next meeting is as yet unclear.

"It is a postponement because several member states wanted more clarification. There will be another meeting when they have more information," said an official at the European Commission. "There wasn't a formal vote and not enough for or against."

The experts' meeting comes less than six months after the EU formally lifted its blockade on new biotech products with an approval, by a legal default procedure, of another GMO maize type made by a different company.

A qualified majority within the EU's weighted voting system is needed for experts - usually from food safety or environment portfolios - either to approve or reject GMO import requests.

If there are insufficient votes, the dossier usually passes to ministers, unless the experts agree with the Commission that a postponement is the best course of action. If ministers cannot agree after three months, the Commission can approve imports.

Monsanto's requested use for the maize, known as MON 863 and modified to resist the corn rootworm insect, is for animal feed and not for growing or for consumption by humans.

FEW COUNTRIES IN FAVOUR

The environment experts did, however, voice opinions at the meeting, although the exact balance of views in the group is hard to establish.

Green groups said only four of thoe country delegations that spoke favoured authorising imports of MON 863 maize. A large number indicated they would abstain, when called upon.

"Disagreements over this GM maize highlight the lack of proper GMO evaluation procedures in Europe," said Eric Gall of international environment group Greenpeace in a statement. "Companies are submitting poor quality data and member states are failing to conduct thorough risk assessments."

The EU remains almost as deeply split over biotechnology as it was in 1998, when several countries said they would reject any new authorisations until the EU's biotech laws were tougher.

Since then, deadlock among EU countries at ministerial and committee level has been the pattern for all attempts by the executive Commission to win a new GMO approval, despite the ban's end.

Any new decision to allow imports would fly in the face of European opinion since more than 70 percent of consumers oppose GMO foods on heath and environment fears.


Story by Jeremy Smith


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
22 SEP 2004
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRIA:
Iran Starts Tests on Uranium for Nuclear Centrifuges

BANGLADESH:
Flood Catastrophe Looms in Bangladesh, Aid Agency

BELGIUM:
EU experts fail to agree on GMO maize imports

CANADA:
Bennett shares drop as Quebec questions emissions

CHINA:
Hong Kong Scientists Advance the Fight Against SARS

CHINA:
China's Energy Crisis Blankets Hong Kong in Smog

FRANCE:
Air Liquide to invest 190 mln euros in Dutch plant

HAITI:
Over 550 dead in Haiti after hurricane spawns floods

INDIA:
Indian Monsoon Seen Below Normal on El Nino Effect

IRAN:
Iran Says No Reason to Halt Nuclear Program

NORWAY:
Russians seen keenest on Montenegrin aluminium firm

SINGAPORE:
YUKOS Cuts Exports To China

SPAIN:
IMF's Rato Sees No Quick Correction to Oil Price

SWITZERLAND:
Treaty Curbs Trade in More Dangerous Chemicals

THAILAND:
Thai Scientists Begin Probe in Big Orangutan Case

THAILAND:
Interpol-Style Effort Needed Against 'Wildlife Mafia'

UK:
Biodiesel firm D1 seeks 20 mln stg in London IPO

UK:
Britain sees no need now for more nuclear power

USA:
California's plans for LNG imports stir debate

USA:
ChevronTexaco Mississippi refinery terminal reopens

USA:
Canada blocks asbestos type from global toxic list

USA:
Bruce Power shuts Ontario Bruce B nuke station

USA:
TB Set to Be Global Scourge Again, Models Predict



previous day
today's news
next day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant