Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Donors, Poor Nations Get Wakeup Call From Tsunami
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

JAPAN: January 13, 2005


TOKYO - The tsunami that devastated Indian Ocean shores has provided a grim reminder to poor nations and the donors that help them that spending money on disaster planning now can save lives and cut relief and rebuilding costs later.


The world has already offered more than $7 billion in emergency relief for victims of the Dec. 26 tsunami that killed more than 157,000 people and left millions homeless in Indonesia, Sri Lanka, Thailand, India and the Maldives.

Experts say investing smaller sums now to tackle problems such as substandard housing could do much to save lives, and because money for long-term projects is scarce in developing nations, wealthy donors play a crucial role.

Reducing the toll disasters take in lives and money is the topic of a Jan. 18-22 conference in Japan's western city of Kobe, which was hit by a 7.3 quake a decade ago that killed 6,433.

"Disaster prevention means using money for something that hasn't happened yet," said Tetsushi Kurita, a senior researcher at the Asian Disaster Reduction Center in Kobe. "Developing nations need to use their money to eat and for things that are taking place right before their eyes.

"When something actually happens, you need to put money into recovery and prevention, such as building houses that won't collapse," Kurita added. "We need to think what we can learn to keep it from happening again."

Worsening matters, people in poor countries often do things that lead to ecological damage, contributing further to natural disasters, experts say.

Deforestation in the Philippines has been blamed for the high death toll in floods there last year, for example.

The destruction in south Asia of natural barriers such as coral reefs and coastal mangrove forests to build hotels and shrimp farms may have left some areas more vulnerable to the tsunami.

"Often, attempts by the poorest to improve their situation backfire," wrote John Mutter, deputy director of Columbia University's Earth Institute, in an article due out soon.

"Unwittingly, a perilous feedback loop is formed in which attempts to cope with poverty amplify the conditions that produce further poverty and put the poor at greater risk."


SIMPLE SOLUTIONS

More than 100 people died in the United States last year when four hurricanes tore through Florida and the Gulf Coast. But the toll from the same storms in Haiti, one of the world's poorest nations which is largely deforested, was in the thousands.

Simple, inexpensive solutions such as reinforcing buildings and disaster planning in local communities are often effective.

"If you strengthen a hospital it might cost $1 million, but if you have to replace it afterwards it might cost $50 million," said Brian Tucker, director of GeoHazards International, a California-based NGO. "More important, though, you save lives."

Breakwaters built around the island of Male in the Maldives cost Japan $500 million in foreign aid over several years and are credited with staving off widespread destruction by the tsunami.

Now Tokyo alone will be spending the same amount for immediate disaster relief for victims of the Dec. 26 tsunami and has pledged to come up with more for rebuilding.

Emergency relief efforts after disaster strikes are increasingly efficient, experts say. But a lack of political will and donor fatigue dampens enthusiasm for the long-term aid that could help keep disasters from taking so many lives.

Good intentions, such as when the United Nations declared the 1990s the "International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction," often come to nought, done in by a lack of firm goals.

Preventive, long-term efforts grab fewer headlines than dramatic disasters, making it hard to persuade governments to provide needed funds.

"When these issues become important for various leaders, they pull the money out from various places," said Max Lawson, policy adviser at aid agency Oxfam. "They always find it somehow.

"We're really keen to see the emergency measures built upon, into not just an emotive reaction but a long-term thing."


Story by Elaine Lies


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
13 JAN 2005
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Worst Australia Bushfires in 20 Years Under Control

BELGIUM:
EU May Send Old Fishing Boats to Tsunami States

BELGIUM:
EU Executive Slams France Over Environmental Law

BELGIUM:
EU Warns UK Over Sewage Treatment

BELGIUM:
World GMO Crop Area Rises by 20 Pct in 2004

BRAZIL:
Six Children, One Adult, Die in Brazil Landslide

CANADA:
Canada's Chief Vet Urges US to Ease Mad Cow Ban

CHINA:
Hong Kong to Test Dead Heron for H5N1 Bird Flu Virus

COSTA RICA:
Costa Rica Declares National Emergency in Floods

GERMANY:
Germany's SolarWorld Seeks Place in the Sun

INDIA:
Indian Tsunami Survivors Seek Shelter Before Rains

INDONESIA:
Andaman Isles Flooded; Indonesia Warns Workers

JAPAN:
Donors, Poor Nations Get Wakeup Call From Tsunami

KENYA:
Britain's Brown Tours Africa Slum, Plants Tree

MAURITIUS:
UN Ready for Indian Ocean Tsunami Alert System by 2006

MAURITIUS:
Review of Tsunami Reef Damage to Take Months

RUSSIA:
Warm Russian Winter Drives Bears Out of Bed

SWITZERLAND:
Disaster Prevention Needs More Than Technology

UK:
Powerful Storm Kills Three in Britain

UK:
UK Says Low Chance of Repeat Boscastle Flood

UK:
Crows Have Natural Tool-Making Ability

UK:
Major UK Human Mad Cow Epidemic Unlikely

UK:
Fossil Fuel Curbs May Speed Global Warming

UK:
Fragile States Need Special Help, Says Britain

UK / RUSSIA:
Russian Rocket Site Linked to Child Sickness

USA:
US West Coast Storms May Have Started in Asia

USA:
California Town Warned as Mudslide Death Toll Hits 10



previous day
today's news
next day