Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Fragile States Need Special Help, Says Britain
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

UK: January 13, 2005


LONDON - The world must stop turning its back on states on the verge of political or economic collapse and instead redouble efforts to ensure that vital aid gets to the people who need it, Britain said on Wednesday.


International Development Secretary Hilary Benn said the speed and scale of the global response to the Asian tsunami disaster showed the world had the capacity to act quickly when necessary -- that lesson simply had to be applied more widely.

"We cannot afford to abandon countries which sit in the 'too difficult' box," Benn told delegates on the eve of an international conference to begin developing a coherent approach to so-called fragile states.

"To prevent human disasters such as that in Darfur and to guard against global insecurity ... it is essential that we prevent countries becoming marginalised and excluded from the benefits of development and poverty reduction," he said.

"These are very difficult questions. But they have to be asked -- and answered," he later told Reuters. "We can't take sides. But the world is moving fitfully towards intervening in fragile states."

He strongly rejected any comparison with US President George W. Bush's doctrine of pre-emptive strikes against perceived failing states which could become enemies.

"This is not retaliatory aid," he said.

Jim Adams, vice president of the World Bank -- one of the conference's prime movers -- said his organisation had been one of the main culprits in walking away from difficult countries or setting them impossible targets. But times had changed.

"We have to learn to take more risks. It is a slow process. We have to lower expectations -- to be prepared for failure," he told Reuters.

Citing examples from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe, Benn said one-third of the people living in absolute poverty were to be found in fragile states -- countries where the rule of law was slipping or non-existent or where civil war was brewing.

These states accounted for 40 percent of all child mortality and their rates of HIV infection were four times those in other developing countries.

"We know that there can be no development without peace and security -- and that conversely, sustainable development is a precondition for long-term peace and security," he said.

Benn, who last month called for a complete overhaul of the UN's crisis relief system which he said had failed millions of people, said the world had to develop an early warning system to detect the imminent collapse of weak states.

Once detected, these states should become a focus for special attention to ensure that specialists remained in place to direct aid and support to the people who most needed it.

"We need to stay involved in fragile states even where the costs are high," Benn said, citing Indonesia's Aceh and northeast Sri Lanka -- devastated by the Asian tsunami but where decades of strife have destroyed trust and made aid distribution far harder.

Benn stressed that staying committed in fragile states demanded a rethink of the standard international aid formula that mostly means that money is withheld until peace prevails.

"As Somalia and southern Sudan have shown, government collapse can last for more than a decade," he said. "It is morally and politically unacceptable to abandon the people in those situations.


Story by Jeremy Lovell


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
13 JAN 2005
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Worst Australia Bushfires in 20 Years Under Control

BELGIUM:
World GMO Crop Area Rises by 20 Pct in 2004

BELGIUM:
EU Warns UK Over Sewage Treatment

BELGIUM:
EU Executive Slams France Over Environmental Law

BELGIUM:
EU May Send Old Fishing Boats to Tsunami States

BRAZIL:
Six Children, One Adult, Die in Brazil Landslide

CANADA:
Canada's Chief Vet Urges US to Ease Mad Cow Ban

CHINA:
Hong Kong to Test Dead Heron for H5N1 Bird Flu Virus

COSTA RICA:
Costa Rica Declares National Emergency in Floods

GERMANY:
Germany's SolarWorld Seeks Place in the Sun

INDIA:
Indian Tsunami Survivors Seek Shelter Before Rains

INDONESIA:
Andaman Isles Flooded; Indonesia Warns Workers

JAPAN:
Donors, Poor Nations Get Wakeup Call From Tsunami

KENYA:
Britain's Brown Tours Africa Slum, Plants Tree

MAURITIUS:
UN Ready for Indian Ocean Tsunami Alert System by 2006

MAURITIUS:
Review of Tsunami Reef Damage to Take Months

RUSSIA:
Warm Russian Winter Drives Bears Out of Bed

SWITZERLAND:
Disaster Prevention Needs More Than Technology

UK:
Powerful Storm Kills Three in Britain

UK:
UK Says Low Chance of Repeat Boscastle Flood

UK:
Fragile States Need Special Help, Says Britain

UK:
Crows Have Natural Tool-Making Ability

UK:
Major UK Human Mad Cow Epidemic Unlikely

UK:
Fossil Fuel Curbs May Speed Global Warming

UK / RUSSIA:
Russian Rocket Site Linked to Child Sickness

USA:
US West Coast Storms May Have Started in Asia

USA:
California Town Warned as Mudslide Death Toll Hits 10



previous day
today's news
next day