Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Leaders Argue Over Global Climate Change Agency
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

UK: May 7, 2007


LONDON - A diplomatic tussle over which world agency should tackle global warming sees France demanding a new UN agency with broad powers, while others say time is short and existing UN bodies must rise to the challenge.


UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon wants to reform the array of UN bodies affected by climate change, whose impact will be felt across the board, leading to upheavals in the security, social, environmental, health and education sectors.

France and others argue no existing body is really equipped to tackle the crisis and a new one should be created.

"We have no problem with a new agency that can speak at cabinet level and has the power to knock a few heads together," said Gordon Shepherd, policy head at WWF International. "But it must not be used as an excuse for governments to do nothing in the meantime."

The French proposal for a United Nations Environment Organisation, originally floated at the Johannesburg Earth Summit in 2002 and revived three years later, has some 40 backers -- mainly from francophone nations.

Ranged against the proposal, for a variety of reasons, are the United States, Brazil and China. The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development has offered its own services.

Environmentalists note at least 20 UN bodies from its environment programme (UNEP) to its refugee agency (UNHCR), health organisation (WHO) and food body (FAO) cover the effects of climate change to some degree.

"There is an existing vehicle," said Shepherd. "It doesn't work very well but it can be helped in the interim while the new agency is set up."

Some diplomats argue the French idea would be a mistake given the need for immediate global action.

Scientists say that burning fossil fuels for power and transport will raise global average temperatures by between 1.8 and 4.0 degrees Celsius this century, leading to worse floods, famines and epidemics and forced migration for millions.

Illustrating the scale of the climate crisis, scientists in the United States have discovered that Arctic ice is retreating three times faster than previously predicted.

"What we have is far from perfect, but it does function to an extent. Starting from scratch now would be like rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic after it hit the iceberg," said a British climate diplomat, on condition of anonymity.

The Kyoto Protocol is the only broad agreement to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases, but the United States rejected it in 2001 on the grounds that its economy would be damaged and that it was not binding on booming emitters China and India.

Kyoto's first phase runs out in 2012 and so far there is no agreement on how to extend and expand it.

There are also major questions over the funding and control of any new UN body, in which both industrialised and developing nations would want high-level representation.


Story by Jeremy Lovell


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
7 MAY 2007
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AFGHANISTAN:
Flood Kills At Least 12 in Northern Afghanistan

AUSTRALIA:
Ivernia Seeks Public OK to Ship Lead From Port

AUSTRALIA:
Baby Nemo Finds No Place Like Home

BELGIUM:
EU Must Speed Response to New GMOs - Farm Chief

BELGIUM:
EU Says Biofuel Target Unlikely to Hit Food Prices

BELGIUM:
EU Demands Estonia Halve Proposed CO2 Cap

BHUTAN:
FEATURE - Bhutan to Pay For Others' Climate Sins

CAYMAN ISLANDS:
Famous Caymans Coral Reefs Dying, Scientists Say

CHINA :
China Plans To Hold First "No Car" Day

CYPRUS:
Environmentalists Slam Cyprus for Spring Bird Hunt

GERMANY:
EU Criticises German Plans for New Coal Power Plants

GERMANY:
EU Should Link with Kyoto Carbon Trade by December 1 [GXYBHTX]

ITALY:
Italy Declares State of Emergency over Drought

JAPAN:
Japan Finance Minister Calls for New Kyoto Protocol Framework

MYANMAR:
Heavy Rains Kill Five in Myanmar's Main City

NETHERLANDS:
INTERVIEW - Dutch Government to Renew Green Energy Subsidies in 2008

NORWAY:
PREVIEW - Governments Meet on Climate: "No Excuse" For Inaction

PHILIPPINES:
Philippines Launches Biofuel, Motorists Wait

SINGAPORE :
Asia Has Few Plans Yet to Deal with Rising Seas

THAILAND:
INTERVIEW - China Calls for Access to Clean Energy Technology

THAILAND:
FACTBOX – UN Findings on Costs of Fighting Global Warming

THAILAND:
Beating Global Warming Needn't Cost The Earth - UN

UK:
Organic Farmers See Prince Charles as Role Model

UK:
Leaders Argue Over Global Climate Change Agency

UK:
Nuclear Industry Welcomes Climate Report Backing

UNITED ARAB EMIRATES:
Oil Slick Closes Dubai Beaches, Clean-Up Launched

USA:
US Rejects 'High Cost' Global Warming Scenarios

USA:
Indigenous Peru Group Threatens to Sue Occidental

USA:
Wind Farms Urged to Go Easy on Birds and Bats

USA:
Search on For Survivors After Kansas Tornado Hits

USA:
Alabama Plant Reopening Marks Nuclear Resurgence?

USA:
US Senate Auto Fuel Plan Proposes 35 MPG by 2020

ZIMBABWE:
Poaching Rises in Zimbabwe's Game Parks - Report



previous day
today's news
next day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant