Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


More EU States Wary on GMO Maize, Debate Hots Up
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

BELGIUM: June 6, 2007


BRUSSELS - Several influential EU states have dug in their heels on whether their farmers may grow one of Europe's oldest genetically modified (GMO) crops, raising the stakes in the EU's long-running stalemate over biotech policy.


The crop is a modified maize variety known as MON 810, marketed by leading US biotech seeds company Monsanto.

Also known by its commercial name YieldGard, the maize type is designed to resist the European corn borer, a pest that attacks maize stalks and thrives in warmer climates in southern EU countries such as Italy and Spain.

While Monsanto says the protein contained in its maize has selective toxicity but is harmless to humans, fish and wildlife, an increasing number of the EU's 27 countries are unconvinced.

National GMO bans are the only part of Europe's biotech debate where EU countries can agree, since they see attempts by Brussels to order a government to lift its ban as an attack on national sovereignty. So, unusually, they tend to band together.

The European Commission has tried this on three occasions in the past two years and got a stinging rebuff on each occasion.

In the past few weeks, two EU agricultural powerhouse countries -- France and Germany -- entered the fray. Not only do they wield huge clout under the bloc's weighted voting system for decision-making, they also grow vast amounts of cereals.

First, Germany's government said maize produced from MON 810 seeds could only be sold if there was an accompanying monitoring plan to research its effects on the environment: a restriction that farmers say is tantamount to a growing ban.

The proposed restriction, to apply from 2008, has already been notified to Commission authorities in Brussels.

Soon afterwards, French government number two Alain Juppe, in charge of his country's environment, transport and energy policy, said in a newspaper interview that he would not exclude being "inspired" by Germany's proposed GMO ban.

Diplomats said it was too early to know if the French and German stances would affect voting for new GMO approvals -- EU countries have clashed over this for years -- but warned that it might alter the balance between 'pro' and 'anti' GMO countries.

"Even a national ban would get them into hot water with the Commission, but if it's a blanket change in position (on biotech policy) then it raises the stakes," one said.


NATIONAL BANS

Austria banned MON 810 maize in June 1999, around 14 months after the EU issued its original authorisation. That national ban was cited, along with several others, by Argentina, Canada and the United States in an international challenge against the European Union at the World Trade Organisation a few years ago.

Hungary, one of the EU-27's biggest grain producers, became the first eastern European country to ban GMO crops or foods when it outlawed the planting of MON 810 seeds in January 2005.

The same year, Greece and Poland used a provision in EU law that allows countries to decide whether to allow GMO seeds on national territory -- although a ban must be approved by EU member states to be legal. Both countries have restrictions in place against MON 810 maize.

Bulgaria's parliament has also indicated support for national restrictions for growing MON 810 maize.

EU environment ministers have slapped down several draft orders authored by the European Commission for countries to rescind their national GMO bans. This happened last February in the case of Hungary and also in December 2006, for Austria.

"We have had two councils (EU ministerial meetings) that have rejected Commission proposals (to lift GMO bans) with a large majority, and now there is this additional case in Germany," a Commission official told Reuters. "We have to look at the whole (GMO) authorisation policy at some point."


Story by Jeremy Smith


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
6 JUN 2007
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Tree Planting, Worm Farming on World Environment Day

BANGLADESH:
Climate Change to Hit Bangladesh Food Output - Experts

BELGIUM:
EU Considers Auctioning 100 Pct of CO2 Permits

BELGIUM:
More EU States Wary on GMO Maize, Debate Hots Up

BHUTAN:
Mines Destroy Bhutan's Mountains, Affect India

BRAZIL:
Brazil Must Improve G8 Climate Proposal - Activists

CANADA:
Airlines Seek to Escape Climate-Change Dog House

CHINA:
China's Pollution Tide Rises But More Slowly

CHINA:
G8 Must Forge Concrete Climate Change Plan - Annan

CHINA:
Drought Hits Nearly 4 Million in Chinese Province

CHINA:
China's Top Power Plant Seen Ready Ahead of Time

CHINA:
Wife of Chinese Green Activist Targets Watchdog

CHINA:
Endangered China Ibises Lose Taste For Wild Life

GERMANY:
Japan, EU Call for 50 Pct Reduction in Emissions

GERMANY:
US Adviser Sees Way Ahead on Post-Kyoto Framework

GERMANY:
Fortis, UN Ink Deal on Financing "Green" Projects

GREECE:
Earthquake Rattles Central Greece, No Injuries

INDONESIA:
Indonesia to Return Rare Kangaroos to Papua Forests

INTERNATIONAL:
Melting Ice: World Environment Day's Hot Topic

ITALY:
Biofuel Can Help Poor as Well as Climate - FAO

MEXICO:
Lion, Tiger Kill Man at Mexican Meat Plant

NETHERLANDS:
Illegal Ivory Imports Flourish In US - Report

NETHERLANDS:
Ebay to Ban Global Ivory Trade on its Sites

NORWAY:
Global Warming May be Good for Greenland

NORWAY:
Financial Firms Urge G8 to Combat Global Warming

NORWAY:
Worries About Global Warming are Growing - Survey

UK:
UK Firms Seek to Curb Formula One C02 Emissions

UK:
World Warmer Than Average in Year to May - UK

UK:
Climate Policies Can't Hurt Us - OPEC

UK:
CO2 Cost Will Make China Curb Emissions - IEA

UK:
Bush Must Join in Global Climate Fight - IEA

UNITED ARAB EMIRATES:
Mideast Cyclone Reaches Oman

US:
US Adopts Limits on Clean Water Law Enforcement

US:
Coke Vows to Reduce Water Used in Drink Production

US:
Honda to Discontinue Accord Hybrid Sedan

US:
Wind to Make 20 Pct of US Power by 2030 - Advocates



previous day
today's news
next day